Player guide · Updated November 2026 · 6 min read
Short answer: A clearly marked proxy is fine in a casual game if the other players agree. It is not allowed in a sanctioned tournament for any major trading card game. Only a judge can issue a proxy there, and only for a card damaged during the event. Selling or trading a copy that could pass as the real card is counterfeiting, and that is where the legal risk sits in Australia.
On this page Where you can use one · Proxy, playtest card or counterfeit · Tournament rules · Australian law · Making an acceptable proxy · FAQs
"Are proxies legal?" is really two questions. One is whether you can play with a stand-in card, which is decided by the game's tournament rules and the people you play with. The other is whether you can make, buy or sell one without legal trouble, which is decided by Australian law. This guide answers both.
Can I use a proxy card?
It depends on where you are playing. Find your situation in the table.
What is the difference between a proxy, a playtest card and a counterfeit?
The difference is whether the card could be mistaken for the real one. Players call all three a "proxy", but publishers and stores do not treat them the same.
- Playtest card: an obvious stand-in used to test a deck. Wizards of the Coast describes it as typically a basic land with another card's name written on it, or a printout sleeved in front of a real card. Nobody could mistake it for the genuine card.
- Proxy (the official meaning): in tournament rules, a proxy is a replacement issued by a judge for a card that was damaged during the event. It is valid for that event only.
- Counterfeit: a copy made to look like the genuine card, with the official art, frame, back and finish. It does not matter whether the seller calls it a "proxy", "replica" or "custom reprint". If it could pass as real, it is a counterfeit.
What do the tournament rules say?
Sanctioned events require genuine cards, and players cannot bring their own proxies. This is the publisher's rule, so a store running an official event has no power to waive it.
- Magic: The Gathering. Wizards of the Coast's policy is that cards used in sanctioned events must be authentic Magic cards. Under section 3.4 of the Magic Tournament Rules, only the Head Judge can issue a proxy, and only for a card accidentally damaged or badly worn during that tournament. A card being expensive or hard to find is not a reason.
- Magic playtest cards. The same Wizards policy says the company has no wish to police playtest cards made for personal, non-commercial use, even when they are used in a store. That is why casual Commander groups use them so widely. It is a statement about casual play, and it does not make them legal in a tournament.
- Pokémon. Play! Pokémon rules do not allow proxy cards in tournaments. A judge can create one for a card damaged during the event, and the player keeps the damaged card as a reference.
- Other games. Yu-Gi-Oh!, Disney Lorcana, Flesh and Blood and One Piece organised play also expect genuine, tournament-legal cards. Check the current tournament rules for your game before an event.
Commander is mostly played casually, so proxies come up there more than anywhere else. If you are choosing a format, our guide to Commander versus Standard explains how the two differ.
Are proxy cards illegal in Australia?
No Australian law mentions proxy cards by name, so the answer comes from copyright, trade mark and consumer law. The closer the card is to the original, and the more money is involved, the higher the risk.
- Writing a card name on a basic land copies no artwork and no logo. It carries no realistic legal risk.
- Printing a card image at home for your own testing does reproduce copyright artwork. Australia's fair dealing exceptions are narrow and do not include a general personal-use right, so this is not clearly permitted. Wizards of the Coast has said it does not want to police playtest cards made for personal use, but that is the company's choice, not a legal right.
- Selling printed copies of official card art, frames and logos is commercial copying of someone else's copyright and trade marks. This is where publishers do act.
- Passing a copy off as genuine in a sale or trade is misleading conduct under the Australian Consumer Law if you are trading as a business, and can be fraud either way.
This is general hobby information, not legal advice. If you plan to make or import custom cards to sell, speak to an Australian lawyer first.
How do I make a proxy other players will accept?
Make it impossible to mistake for the real card and easy to read across the table. A card that fails either test is the kind other players object to.
- Ask the group or the organiser before the game, not during it.
- Use a basic land or a spare common with the card name written clearly on it, or a paper printout sleeved in front of a real card.
- Use the same opaque sleeves for the whole deck so proxies cannot be told apart from the back.
- Keep the official card text ready on your phone for rules questions.
- Do not buy printed proxies with the official card back. They are the ones that get mistaken for real cards later.
- Store proxies apart from your collection and never put one in a trade binder.
If you are proxying a card to test it, the next step is usually buying the one copy you need. You can find it in our single cards range, and our guide to single cards versus sealed product explains when singles are the cheaper route.
How do I avoid buying a counterfeit by mistake?
Treat any listing that uses the words "proxy", "replica" or "reprint" for a card with official art as a counterfeit, whatever the seller says. Other warning signs:
- A price far below what the card sells for elsewhere.
- Claims that the card is "indistinguishable from real" or "tournament quality".
- No photo of the back, or only stock images.
- Blurry text, colours that look washed out or too dark, or card stock that feels thinner or glossier than a genuine card from the same set.
Compare a doubtful card side by side with a genuine one from the same set. Our card condition guide for buyers covers what to look at when you inspect a card.
Frequently asked questions
Are proxy cards legal in Australia?
Using a hand-marked stand-in in a casual game breaks no law. Printing copies of official card art is not clearly covered by any copyright exception, and selling such copies or passing them off as genuine can breach copyright, trade mark and consumer law.
Can I use proxies in Commander?
In a private game, yes, if your playgroup agrees. At a store, ask the organiser first. Sanctioned Commander events follow the same rule as any other sanctioned Magic event: genuine cards only.
Are proxies allowed at Friday Night Magic?
No. Friday Night Magic is a sanctioned event, so every card must be an authentic Magic card. The only exception is a proxy issued by the Head Judge for a card damaged during that event.
Is it illegal to buy proxy Magic or Pokémon cards online?
Printed copies that use the official art and card back are counterfeits, however the listing describes them. The seller carries most of the legal risk, but you cannot use the cards in tournaments, and reselling or trading them as genuine would put you at risk too.
What is the difference between a proxy and a fake card?
A proxy is an obvious stand-in that nobody could mistake for the real card. A fake, or counterfeit, is made to look genuine. The test is whether another person could be fooled.
Why do stores restrict proxies?
Stores that run official events must follow the publisher's rules to keep running them. Stores also buy, sell and trade genuine singles, so realistic copies on the tables make every trade harder to trust.
Related guides: Commander vs Standard · Single cards versus sealed product · Card condition guide for buyers
About the rules quoted. Tournament rules were checked on 19 November 2026 against Wizards of the Coast's proxy policy statement and section 3.4 of the Magic Tournament Rules. Publishers update their rules, so check the current version for your game before an event.